ok, why can't anyone be more original. Biancas good but the songs are the same as the ones Tiffany Evans sang on Star Search two years ago. Bianca competed against Tiffany at that time. They even have the same vocal coach-- style and songs are the same. Tiffany wowed the audience then too. Their style of singing and song choices are the same. How much do you want to bet the next song is "I am changing" or "Smile"! America is too intelligent for a second Tiffany. Come on who wants to see another 11-12 year old kid belting out a song just like the next girl and the next girl. Sure it's showy and loud, but where is the soul and compassion that separates one 11 year old singer from another? I want to hear variety and be entertained for more than two minutes.

Where you entertained for the two minutes the judges gave the BIRDLADY?

Give me a break...

Well, personally, I never heard of the song (or Dreamgirlss for that matter) before she sang it, so it was pretty original from my perspective.

I personally also never heard of this Dreamgirls until Bianca sang it.Let alone knew of Jennifer Holiday at all. Who cares if someone else sang the songs before. Everyone sings song of other people . She sang it great and thats all that matters. We always hear Whitney, Celion Dion, Martina Mcbride. They choose songs from great singers, so I say if you can sing it Then more power to you,.

The girl is ELEVEN years old. ELEVEN !

How mean adults can be to rip and shred an ELEVEN year old to pieces !
Do you not have children or nieces and nephews in that age?
Would you tear them apart like you are doing now?
Would you allow anyone to speak about them like you are all doing?

I THINK NOT.

The show is LAME to begin with. 2 hours of breaks !!!

When Bianca Ryan is releasing her album in a few years, or hosting her own 1 hour show on NBC
You can say I ripped her way back when.....

The girl will win and she will be a household name selling out arenas by this time next year.

Selling out arenas or not, she'll be nothing but a novelty act because of her age. Singers are a dime a dozen, and I'd watch American Idol if I wanted to see them. Even if she hits it big, in 10 years she'll just be another singer that gets overplayed on a radio. Why do we need another one?

the chicken believes that monkeys are ransacking this thread with their weapons of mass destruction because the pope is islamic and trades pokemon cards with the queen of zimbabwe because haiti is the capital of the world with a llama named gus

Well I didn't see tiffiny sing this song or ever hear the song before I saw Bianca sing it so I guess its new to me along with probibly millions of other people. This was a really stupid post. Im glad Bianca sang it again because she was incredible. I went to youtube and watched Tiffiny sing it after I read your post. She was good. Bianca is great.

I had never watched the Star Search episode with Tiffani or Bianca so this song was new to me by them. I had heard the Jennifer Holliday version and loved the song. I thought Bianca did better than Tiffani on it and was clearer and more concise with her words. I watch AGT for all the entertainment, to see the different types of talent, whether they are 8 or 80, some I don't like, but some I do. Who is on the show and who will make it to the finals is not a matter of life or death, if it is all singing based and a singer wins it, that only means that the majority of America chooses to listen to singing rather than watch juggling, magicians, or acrobatics, which I enjoyed watching all of those, also.