Boy NBC producers sure got it wrong with this show.

1. WE DO NOT NEED ANOTHER AMERICAN IDOL! Look if you are only going to put through singers and dancers than you have not improved this type of show.

2. No talent judges. David Hasslehoft is NOT a qualified judge of talent. Brandi MIGHT be able to see past her knowledge base but still, is only qualified to judge some types of singing. The Brit, well I do not know what the heck he is there for. It is an OBVIOUS attempt to create another Simon.

3. The put just about anyone through if it made good TV. Watching that show I was just amazed at what they considered talent and what they did not. Again, they should have talent agents as judges.

4. Inside info from a contestant has stated that most of this is a set up as to who will make better TV.

5. Judges ARE TOO EASY ON KIDS. Sorry, if you want to play with the big boys you have to be honest. Some just are not up to the million dollar level.

6. Judges can not tell talent that they are a one trick pony. HELLO, JUDGES READ THIS- IT IS CALLED AMERICA's GOT TALENT. TALENT- NOT MULIT TALENT. Why do you equate a signer or dancer as MULIT TALENTED? THey are not. They all did the SAME thing in their style.


If you want the show to be a hit you need to be honest that the kids hit wrong notes and not put them through. Really all were a bit too faced. They CLAIM the acts were the same yet when they put someone through who did the same act like the yodel girl, they said she was better than before. No offense, they all were about the same so why favor the kid.

You have to stop only favoring singing and dance groups. WE HAVE ENOUGH IDOL SHOWS. That poor girl, she does not know you are favoring her for the TV not becasue she is worth the top prize. We all know you are just trying to keep some kids and novelty acts in the show to stretch it. You know that if you did not, everyone woudl just say you are weak IDOL.


Well I am a so disappointed in this show.
It is not fair to weed out some of the good variety acts BEFORE I can vote. I might accept that if you had qualified judges but you do not.

Time to retool if you think you have a shot for next year.

Really focus on diversity if you want to be around as long as Idol. [size=1]