I don't feel that At Last should have been picked over Badfingers... Badfingers was amazing and different, and to me worth a million... Do you agree with me? if not then why?

If an act isn't good enough to get me to pay $30 for a 1 hour show I don't think they're worth a million. I wouldn't pay 410 to see Bobby Bad Fingers perform for an hour. Mayeb with 4 or 5 other acts for 10 to 15 minutes each, but not on his own

,Matt

well, yeah badfingers does have talent.. but I don't think talent worth a million. Hundred maybe.
xD

of course At Last would be worth more since they sing, but my point is that he is different and what the point of the show is... this show is becoming an american idol and that is really dumb to me... At Last wasn't that great they have projection issues...

Yeah, his talent is unique.. the thing is his act may be a little too short, he can only snap for like 2 minutes until he it gets a little boring. As for at last, they can't exactly try for american idol, cause they are a group... i liked the harmony though. =D

that's jusr what i think.

duh... what is so unique about singing? At Last has no energy, but Badfingers can work a crowd.. I agreed with the judges completely!

No way! Badfingers was okay, but At Last is winning the 1mil! They are great; didn't you notice all the people in the Audience with At Last signs?

yeah but thats how i feel... they seem like a dull harmony singing bunch of guys!! Theres nothing different about them to any other harmony boy band...

do you want to see a revival of boy bands like Nsnyc and backstreet boys? I sure dont leave that in the 90s

Well what's so unique about snapping? I can snap too. He just snaps better than me... and At Last things better than me too. so well leave it at that.

I guarantee that you cant snap as fast as him and he creates energy, which is amazing... at last is nothing but a boy band reject

This show is not american idol. It is best talent wins. why is that so hard to understand? If its the best talent then its the best. A child like Bianca ( who is a star win or loose) is not the right age for american idol. They did not say she couldnt try out for AGT because shes a singer. She will be a star one day regardless. She is simply gifted.

Thank you!
God, I don't understand what is so hard to understand about this. Singing is as much a talent as anything else we've seen on this show! So why try to say it isn't! And American Idol DOES have restrictions, so there's a better chance of a wide range of singers to get recgonized on a show like AGT.

You asked--I don't agree. Bobby Badfingers is very good and entertaining, but he showed Wed. night that he can't snap for more than a minute without having to do something else. His dance didn't show much talent in the way of snapping. Good, but not worth a million. Another thing is At Last was picked by the voters, so enough of America didn't agree with you either. Sorry.

i think bobby badfingers it was really great and original, all this singers winning go to american ideol! from the 4 finails , one peir acrobat, the other 3 are music , are the judges so ignorant that they can not judge anything else that it is not music?
they think that judglic, acrobats, etc... you learn in an hour!
i feel sorry for the 8 year old girl, this is to have talent , not the other singers, they are like another group!

You feel sorry for the 8 year old girl? I'm sorry - what? She way too many mistakes, and although she has the talent to become a great piano player in the future, she's not at that level now. As for Bobby Badfingers, he was... well, boring. He also threw in a lame dance in the middle, which just about killed my support. I'd say his act's maximum worth would be 200. 500 at most. Definitely NOT 1 million. And American Idol has restrictions. Groups don't get the opportunity to showcase their talent.
And is your hatred of singers so great that you would rather put in a less talented little girl over a group of very talented singers? Obviously America didn't feel the same. At Last won; America has spoken; the end.

Maybe Fingers and the Horn Guy can team up. Than they will be twice as annoying.