NBC > SHAME SHAME SHAME

tugirls

Jul 20 2006, 08:53 PM

Now, that the judges are judging to have a MIX of talents in the last contest will we see 'like talents' go up against each other? To have a fair chance for all ... like talents MUST go up against each other. Get the BEST individual singer, then the BEST singing group, then the BEST piano player, etc etc. Otherwise you will not be fair to each section of talents nor get the BEST of each group.

NBC Execs ... will we being seeing a different show format? - Such as, all piano players on one show so we can see them all together and get the very BEST of each sector to compete for the million dollars against each other.

Thanks for the opt to express my observations - tugirls

aleams22

Jul 20 2006, 09:29 PM

QUOTE (tugirls @ Jul 20 2006, 09:53 PM)

Now, that the judges are judging to have a MIX of talents in the last contest will we see 'like talents' go up against each other? To have a fair chance for all ... like talents MUST go up against each other. Get the BEST individual singer, then the BEST singing group, then the BEST piano player, etc etc. Otherwise you will not be fair to each section of talents nor get the BEST of each group.

NBC Execs ... will we being seeing a different show format? - Such as, all piano players on one show so we can see them all together and get the very BEST of each sector to compete for the million dollars against each other.

Thanks for the opt to express my observations - tugirls

if you put the best individual singer and best group and so on then you are basicly following a path like American Idol or StarSearch but with additional categories...

sub

Jul 20 2006, 09:38 PM

QUOTE (tugirls @ Jul 20 2006, 09:53 PM)

Now, that the judges are judging to have a MIX of talents in the last contest will we see 'like talents' go up against each other? To have a fair chance for all ... like talents MUST go up against each other. Get the BEST individual singer, then the BEST singing group, then the BEST piano player, etc etc. Otherwise you will not be fair to each section of talents nor get the BEST of each group.

NBC Execs ... will we being seeing a different show format? - Such as, all piano players on one show so we can see them all together and get the very BEST of each sector to compete for the million dollars against each other.

Thanks for the opt to express my observations - tugirls

QUOTE (superman22 @ Jul 20 2006, 10:29 PM)

if you put the best individual singer and best group and so on then you are basicly following a path like American Idol or StarSearch but with additional categories...

The people voted for who they thought had a better 'talent' and it ended up that people like some talents more than the other weird talents [Male stripper? C'mon people]. I also see that Tugirls suggests that NBC makes another show based in your opinion. Don't forget: it costs lots of money to get all these people together and make a show, they cant just do things as one person likes. Try making a show like that yourself (good luck), I like America's Got Talent better whatsoever.

aleams22

Jul 20 2006, 09:47 PM

QUOTE (sub @ Jul 20 2006, 10:38 PM)

The people voted for who they thought had a better 'talent' and it ended up that people like some talents more than the other weird talents [Male stripper? C'mon people]. I also see that Tugirls suggests that NBC makes another show based in your opinion. Don't forget: it costs lots of money to get all these people together and make a show, they cant just do things as one person likes. Try making a show like that yourself (good luck), I like America's Got Talent better whatsoever.

If they never showcased singing then I wouldnt be saying this... you obviously dont get my point... whats the point of another singing show if you already have shows that do that? that makes this show no different. You think that I just like something different then thr same boring singing groups. You are sadly mistaken... This show wasnt intended to be a mostly singing tv show, because American Idol is that kind of show... not this one

sub

Jul 20 2006, 10:07 PM

QUOTE (superman22 @ Jul 20 2006, 10:47 PM)

If they never showcased singing then I wouldnt be saying this... you obviously dont get my point... whats the point of another singing show if you already have shows that do that? that makes this show no different. You think that I just like something different then thr same boring singing groups. You are sadly mistaken... This show wasnt intended to be a mostly singing tv show, because American Idol is that kind of show... not this one

Then I guess people like singing-based talents more than others. That's America's vote for ya.

AElfwynn

Jul 21 2006, 12:23 PM

QUOTE (sub @ Jul 20 2006, 11:07 PM)

Then I guess people like singing-based talents more than others. That's America's vote for ya.

And we're all aware of how discriminating America is, right?

grammo

Jul 21 2006, 12:58 PM

QUOTE (tugirls @ Jul 20 2006, 08:53 PM)

Now, that the judges are judging to have a MIX of talents in the last contest will we see 'like talents' go up against each other? To have a fair chance for all ... like talents MUST go up against each other. Get the BEST individual singer, then the BEST singing group, then the BEST piano player, etc etc. Otherwise you will not be fair to each section of talents nor get the BEST of each group.

NBC Execs ... will we being seeing a different show format? - Such as, all piano players on one show so we can see them all together and get the very BEST of each sector to compete for the million dollars against each other.

Thanks for the opt to express my observations - tugirls

I like your idea! Sort of like kennel club shows. Best of breed, best of group, then best of show.

(I don't at all mean that to sound snide. It's just the competition that leapt to mind.)

Give more time to the talent. Get judges that actually know something about the categories. Dispense with trying to simultaneously judge and balance the final show.

I like it.