QUOTE (BlueTurfBronco1 @ Nov 27 2007, 12:47 PM)

IMDB's Top 250I've seen about 90 of them, but I have some major objections to this list...
Me too. No objections to The Godfather at no.1. From there on, though (and I've seen over a hundred of these)...
First the ones I
agree with: Schindler's List and Casablanca. 12 Angry Men, Rear Window, Goodfellas, Raiders of the Lost Ark, Psycho, Dr Strangelove, Citizen Kane (although it should be higher than 24 - I'd make it no lower than 5), North By Northwest, M (should be Top 10), Double Indemnity (my personal no. 1), Metropolis (at 67??)?
No issues. The Apartment should be much higher.
BUT:
Pulp Fiction is a
horrible movie. Shouldn't even
be on the list. Same for Fight Club, as well as any LOTR.
No Country For Old Men?? Geez, who paid to have that one put on?
Ratatouille? Same thing - I loved it, but it's like saying the wine is great when the grapes have just been pressed. American Gangster??
It's a little early, don't you think... Looks to me like some studios bought their way onto this list.. Little Miss Sunshine ahead of Bonnie and Clyde, or In Cold Blood? Sorry, Steve, it was good, but not
that good. What's next? License To Wed in the Top 30?
And I'm only through the first 100...but where are Stagecoach, Birth of a Nation, Intolerance? The Battleship Potemkin? The Cabinet of Dr Caligari, The Grand Illusion? Scarface (the original), White Heat? Where are they?
I'd rather see a list where no film released in the last 5 years was eligible. It lets people sit back at review a film on its merits, instead of the hype. And that includes films I like, such as Ratatouille.
The problem with favourite-anything-of-all-time lists is that they're subjective. Preferences and prejudices factor into how something 'rates'. My list and yours will be radically different, and that's fine. Something on your list may tweak my interest, and if I see it and like it, I may change my list. So this is
really just a snapshot in time, taken by a bunch of faceless people, and possibly influenced by studio publicists, and of course, money. Keep that in mind when you go to the video store next time.
Now for the bottom 250....some of these are so bad they've become cult classics (The Hellcats), or are just train wrecks (Glitter). But everyone knows that Gigli is the worst film ever made, by miles.