What is the deal with scrubs becoming so dramatic??? I mean dont get me wrong I like a little drama but the reason I love scrubs is that it isnt as dramatic as most shows on tv.
And what is J.D.'s deal he has had more than enough chances with Elliot!!

I liked it, i dont care what ppl say... i still enjoy scrubs. you need the drama if you are wrapping up a show or a season.

i agreee 100% true fans respec what the characters r going through and they live it with them

not dis the show good episode and a good season

yeah .. i do hear you though, i miss the great one liners and jd daydreams.

i do too and so long as over the season they keep the amount of drama and comedy equal its good (maybe a bit more comedy over drama)

AMEN!

Seriously, I still like this show, but I miss the funny. What have they done to The Todd???

Don't get me wrong; I like drama a little more than I'd like (Buffy fan), but it didn't start out like this. If I wanted to watch a dramatic show, I wouldn't have turned the TV off when ER came on...

Actually, I thought tonight's was really funny. I didn't think it was overly dramatic. I mean, the original proposal wasn't dramatic, emotional, or even heartwarming as she took back her "Yes," because the ring didn't fit and everything wasn't the way she dreamed it. She planned her own surprise proposal. Everyone imagining what it would be like to be married to Elliot was at least interesting and some of the best moments in the episode.

As for J.D., he's a selfish ***. He said the exact same thing years ago when Elliot and Sean were going to live together. Once she chose him, he no longer wanted her. He's lonely, she's happy with Keith and they're going to be getting married. He's jealous. I hope he gets over it, or maybe when Kim comes back they can maybe spark something up, (taking it they can resolve the obvious problem). I don't really have a problem with J.D. and Elliot being together. I just hope it's not because he ruins their relationship and she's stupid enough to go to him again.

136. My Cold Shower

First aired: 5/3/2007 Production Code: 619

J.D. tries to get together with Elliot's sorority sister Melody, but she just wants to make out with him without going further. Keith re-proposes to Elliot after she gets to make everything perfect, while everyone has fantasies about being married to Elliot. Elliot and Carla are having problems figuring out what is wrong with two elderly patients, who show the same symptoms but have no obvious connection.

Writer: Janae Bakken
Director: John Inwood
Guest star: Robert Maschio (Dr. Todd Quinlan), Travis Schuldt (Keith), Johnny Kastl (Dr. Doug Murphy), Christa Miller-Lawrence (Jordan Sullivan), Randall Winston (Leonard), Frank Encarnacao (Dr. Mickhead) , Cantrell Harris (Policeman), Keri Russell (Melody O'Harra), Chris Dougherty (Jamie), Bruce Kirby (Mr. Bilbray), Marjorie Lovett (Mrs. Sheldon)