QUOTE (sun41 @ Apr 10 2008, 04:29 PM)

There seemed to me to be inconsistencies with the way they wrote him, or at least less explanation. He did start out as a drunk with no motivation, but then later he clearly tells Hiro you gave me a purpose, for being. Made something of me. He really wants to do the right then, he is not evil then, or crazy, and it doesn't seem he has no morals. We're not shown that.
Completely disagree.
He started as a worthless drunk. He was shown how to be a Hero, and seized that opportunity.
However, he feels, Hiro betrayed him. That started nudging him back along the wrong path. Follow that with over 4 centuries in which he has seen "humanity for what it is."
That means he's survived, and probably fought in every major war I can think of off hand. Definitely the Revolution, Civil War, The War To End All Wars (WW I), and the one that followed it (WW II).
Adam has
chosen his path, the path of the villain. We're shown the choices he made to be evil.
QUOTE (sun41 @ Apr 10 2008, 04:29 PM)

So he thinks humanity has never learned its lessons with war, global warming ect and wants to do a good clean sweep to save us from ourselves, but then, to have him say, and if-- there's anyone left I can be their hero. Ah, if there's no one left, there won't be anyone to be a hero for. You have to want someone to be left Adam. You'll be living by yourself for the next century. That dialogue made no sense.
Actually, the dialogue made perfect sense, it just didn't work on a surface level.
That dialogue proved him to be every bit as messed up as Sylar, just in a different level. He has a Messiah Complex. It's a very real psychological issue. He
has to be the Hero- even if it means
he is the reason a Hero is needed. (There are very real cases of people creating disasters just so they can sweep in and rescue the endangered. Unfortunately, it rarely works out.)
QUOTE (sun41 @ Apr 10 2008, 04:29 PM)

They made us sympathize with Elle, so Adam can be not all bad.
Not the same at all. They made us sympathize with Elle because they showed us that most of her problem is Bob. Whatever he did to her, this is what Noah says about her, "I was there. When your father first brought you in.
You were a normal girl. Unicorns and rainbows. And then they started the testing. The human brain isn't built to take that much electricity. You poor girl."
In other words, Bob is the reason her brain is messed up. Combine that with his constant beating down of her psyche, making her crave his approval no matter what it takes, you have a messed up girl through no fault of her own.
Adam, on the other hand, is messed up
entirely through his own doing- and he's completely "bad."
QUOTE (sun41 @ Apr 10 2008, 04:29 PM)

I like glimpses of the past, him trying to be a hero, through the 400 years he was alive, but then eventually, after seeing anyone he cared about die, and people not changing become who he is now, that would be great.
That's something you're unlikely to see. He's selfish. That's something we saw even back when he was trying to be the Kensei. The
only reason he wanted to be the hero was to get the girl.
I'm sorry... I
like the character, I really do. DA's a tremendous actor, and the character is an exquisite villain (although not comparable to Sylar), but trying to make the character somehow something/someone
other than he is will ruin him.