What an awesome post -- and one I have pages of opinion on. First off, let me say this. I was a lukewarm Days viewer for years until I heard my favorite one-eyed dude was coming back on the scene alongside Kayla. I was ECSTATIC, and began watching everyday again. However, the Steve and Kayla storyline started to grow boring after awhile, and I would have STOPPED watching, even with my beloved Patch back on, had it not been for EJ. Seriously. He's the reason I stayed, and that says a lot about James Scott as an actor AND EJ as a character.
Here is my first point, and it is one I'd like to pound home times a thousand. Days of Our Lives BIGGEST problem IMO is its inconsistency, and it has been plaguing the show since JER left the second time in the late 90's. That was when soaps in general started to decline and the internet began gaining ground. People didn't have to watch everyday to find out what happened, and so overall viewership dropped. For days, the declining ratings found Corday turning over headwriters at a rapid pace. Each new headwriter inherited the previous ones nightmare, and before they had a chance to fix anything they were canned as well...........case in point, EJ WELLS.
I am going to call him EJ WELLS, because honestly, I don't think JERk would have ever made him Elvis. I think he created EJ to be a Dimera, but not to be Susan's spawn. JER created EJ for Sami, so that she would finally have someone that understood her and had her same MO, only their 'angst' would have eventually turned out to be the fact that he was a Dimera. It was that fated Romeo and Juliet tale, only I doubt with Reilly at the helm that it would have been as 'romantic.' At any rate, JER also created EJ for James Scott, hoping he'd be able to get the actor to sign. Clearly he invisioned an EJAMI pairing.........Reilly also coincided EJ's arrival with the gloved hand story, but he wrote it as if EJ wasn't the gloved hand. I don't think he was. When Hogan arrived his first order of business was to wrap the gloved hand stuff up, and in doing so he hypothesized a ludicrous scenario of Patrick and EJ, when any of us watching daily could have told him that it was IMPOSSIBLE for one of these guys to be in Cincinatti as the gloved hand while BOTH were seen in Salem at the same time. Grrrr. Anyway, my point is that EJ's character arrived in Salem -- not as a pawn of Stefano's, but as a mysterious man hiding his Dimera past that was genuinely interested in Sami and the rest of Salem. He understood Sami like no other, and for the first time I was drawn in. Hogan, upon directing his interim writer, tried to capitalize on the EJAMI chemistry by turning it into EJ being a he-devil obsessed, creating a few tender scenes of them connecting and kissing that the audience perceived as 'fake' because we already knew he was the gloved hand. Why? Because Hogan told us in all the soap mags and spoilers. He wanted people to turn on the idea of an EJAMI pairing so he could get away from Reilly's vision and turn on his own.
That, dear posters, was the first mistake with EJ. A new writer came on and changed his character's intentions in order to reunite Lucas and Sami and turn EJ and Sami fans away from the couple. He decided the first way to do that, to make EJ's 'love' of Sami seem unlegitimate, was to pair the guy with Kate. When that didn't work, he went on to have that awful December 29 scene........
Don't get me wrong though. Hogan is the one that wrote for EJ for over a year, and he did a decent job. I think he understood some of Reilly's vision, but just didn't want EJ with Sami and thus turned him into an obsessed Dimera freak ala. Stefano. He capitalized on two fanbases animosity toward one another and tried giving either side false hope so they would stick around. In doing so, he used the EJAMI chemistry opposite of this vile man named EJ. Seriously, I wanted to HATE EJ for what happened with Sami. I really did. I wanted to cringe with their scenes in the police department in January of 07. I did! But I couldn't. I LOVED the wicked EJ. He was delicious -- and if nothing else he brought out the villianous Sami again, who I had grown to love over the years and missed terribly. Hogan's idea of redemption was to whiddle a character down to zero personality IMO. I'm not into that type of redemption. People talk about how EJ has become a sap, and I stress that this is what happened to Sami as well.
I realize that EJ was letting Sami yank him around like a puppy, but this had only been going on since the summer of 2007. Prior to that, obsessed EJ or not, he was FRIGHTENING. That beating he gave Patrick? That taunting he did to Sami at the police station and during her first few months after learning she was pregnant? Oh my -- James Scott ruled in that role. He thrived. EJ THUMPED. And then came this idea to redeem him, to turn him into a Sami -- spineless and indecisive. Both used to be strong, determined, and decisive beyond reason.
QUOTE
I am sure it is resentment maybe - because he is interested in Nicole? I can understand why that would upset EJAMI but I just don't know what was so appealing about EJ before he stood up to Sami.
I don't resent Nicole. I just don't understand why people seem to forget the famous tango scene. Even those fans who have always been anti-EJAMI, I don't see how even they can deny the chemistry, or at the very least the execution of that scene. It was brilliant, classic soap that didn't need to use sex in an elevator or a drawn out pub conversation about a future date to drive home the electrical impulses between two people. Even though I don't dislike EJOLE, I have to admit that those two could never pull off the tango scene. That's probably one of the best EJ scenes out there, with the exception of the scene when he and Sami went over to Lexi's to confront her and EJ stuck his foot in the door to prevent her from shutting it. To me, those two scenes reflect what EJ is all about -- sensuality, romance without words, and the sort of frightening 'I mean business' force that can be shown by as simple an action as sticking one's foot in the door. What I want to know is what happened to that EJ ??????? I agree with those that say Dena doesn't know how to write for EJ -- but only because I think that EJ was already so lopsided when she came aboard. If she would watch the tango episode and the EJ/Sami confront Lexi confrontation than she'd be set. Ej shouldn't have to be Sami's lapdog, but he shouldn't demean himself into being Nicole's 'redemption' either.