Okay everyone keep in mind pass deeds. I know they've tried to make Sami some type of heroine but I'm sorry I've watched this show for 15 years and I just can not buy good girl Sami.

Sami will always be (morally) the worst character. I do however enjoy bad Sami more than Sami who cries all of the time everyday all day and whimpers and is helpless.

I've actually always liked Nicole. I've always understood where she was coming from. She is a villainess but I like villainess as long as it makes sense.

Kate is my absolute favorite character ever but this out of character illogical irrational poorly plotted plan against Chloe has ruined her.

So my pick is Scami. Were EJ out of the picture I would say that the kid is better off with Nicole actually. And yes I am holding a grudge.

Sami (Samaaaaaaantha ) is worse and I agree that Sydney is better off in Nicole's care.

Nicole is far worse than Sami. Nicole is the one who lied about a miscarriage, faked a pregnancy, switched two babies like objects and is a baby thief. Not to mention how she's been manipulating everyone around her and is now has the nerve to act like some noble wife and mother after what she's done.

Nicole doesn't deserve to have Sydney or EJ.

I love Nicole and Sami. They've both done terrible things, but they still are redeemable. To me, it doesn't matter who's done worse

They Both have Done Bad,Horrible Things but i say Nicole's Worse.

Nicole is far worse than Sami...All this cr** wouldn't be happening if it wasn't for her. Nicole makes the perfect villianess.

They have both done bad things, but Nicole is far worse, IMO.

Sami wins hands down, as far as her past deeds. But Nicole wins as far as the baby switch..

Oh I say its a tie.

Def Nicole,

So in my biased opinion it would have to be Nicole. But truth be told they're both morally inept (when considering their past deeds).

Mercy, it's Nicole who went toooooo far. But I agree that Sami has really pulled some really bad stuff. I can't stand EJ, JMHO>

I have to agree with you. Sami is no angel. But Nicole is far worse imo.

Nicole,for sure.

I just wanted to add:

Nicole takes the cake. How exactly is Sydney better off in her care? Nicole stole that child and has no idea about her medical history, so Lexie is also in the dark not knowing about Sydney and the medical problem she had when she was born. Sorry, I don't buy that somehow Nicole is a better "mother" than Sami either. Nicole did this all for herself and not for anyone else. How is that being a good parent and putting a child first? It isn't. I don't like Sami did either but in her mind she was protecting Grace from Stefano. And that I don't blame her for. She should of told EJ before, granted. But keep in mind that Nicole found out about Sami's pregnancy and still didn't tell EJ. And now,Nicole will most likely be an accessory to the murder of Dr. Baker, and let's not forget her little involvement in Tony's death also. Nicole gets my vote for being so utterly despicable, selfish and pathetic in this situation.

Oh good grief,, it's Nicki, they both have done bad things but Niki is the worst~

For me it's Nicole with Sami coming in a close 2nd.

Both are equal

I disagree, Nicole is the worst evil. ever She trade the baby from Sami. I couldn't wait her face crying.

hurry Sami and Ej reunite!

It's a good thing that this is a soap opera! If
someone pulled off the kind of stuff Nicole and Sami have
done, goodnight Irene, they would be behind bars for sure. Especially poor Nicole, she actually kidnapped Sami's baby. Of course on soap operas you can do just about anything, even if you are on of the main characters.

Sami hands down, I don`t buy her good girl act either.

I hate Nicole all my heart. I love Samantha Jean Brady!

They're equally bad if you look at what Sami has done in the past.

Like watching Nicole better, because she doesn't wine.
I can only tolerate Sami when she's with EJ. Overall she's too whiny & blubbers ways too much.

Nicole is wacko that's for sure. She doesn't deserve to live...She is the most vindictive, snarky and self centered character ever. She is right up there with Kate. I for one can't wait to see her downfall and sincerely hope that EJ and Sami give it to her big time and that Brady is so angry at her that he refuses to even talk to her ever again.

That really is a hard question, because both have done bad things.. This is why I think that they should make good friends.. They can compare notes, wouldn't it be a hoot?? Both would get testy with each other because the one ousted the other in the bad things that they have done....

On the whole, they're about even.

Currently, while Nicole switched babies, she has made it that Sydney knows her father and not her mother.

BUT, Sami would have never allowed EJ to know his daughter so that's a wash.

I vote that it's a tie.

I have to disagree with this.

All this cr** wouldn't be happening if it weren't for Sami & her actions.

I think Nicole is worse...but both are bad as hell...

Stepford Sami I can't stand....this whiny blubbering Sami is not the Samanatha Jean Brady we have watched and cheered for all these years!

They have both done bad things in the past, but as for the present its Nicole! There are soo many extenuating circumstances involved in this S/L but when it all boils down - Nicole stole a baby! Every person involved can be made accountable, Ej and his wicked DiMera ways, Sami for not letting him know she was pregnant, Mia for not telling ANYONE she was pregnant but as far as actions go only Nicole is still scheming and manipulating to keep 'the family' she 'built'. She stole someone elses child! You cant get much lower than that.

there is NOWAY Nicole is a better mom then Sami. Nicole is only in it for the money! She STOLE Samies baby for goodness sake and let Sami think her baby died! Who with any morals could ever do something like that? Sami is a way better mom and should have her baby returned!!

this is the beauty of soaps. it dont really matter how illegal or immoral or horrible what anyone does. this is just the place for stories like that, its soap opera bread and butter lol. but i root for sami always cause i can relate to her more.

Nicole is worse than Sami. Sami used to be pretty bad, but she has grown up alot. I see her, in the future, as a strong, street-smart person that we can root for. She will give EJ a run for his money, and make him a better person. Niccole, on the other hand, is pathetic. What she has done is unforgivable, and she has the gall to defend it--like she is doing everyone a favor by stealing someone else's baby. She acts like she actually believes that stealing Sami's baby was an unselfish act. She did it because she knew she could not keep EJ any other way.

Honestly...

I think Sydney would have been better off with Nicole than with Sami. For the time that she has had her, Nicole has been attentive, loving and completely devoted to Sydney. Sami would have ended up using Sydney for leverage somehow.

Nicole cherishes Sydney. Sami lies to her children and I don't remember when we have seen her actually cuddle Allie or Johnny (though I know that's mostly the writing maybe).

I think because Sami can just have kids anytime she wants and seems to be Salem's baby machine versus Nicole who has been told she can't have children and may never have children again, Sami ends up taking her children for granted.

Children aside though, I would rather watch Nicole than Sami any day.

it's sami's fault nicole had a miscarriage, lied about it, and stole sami's baby after promising mia she would love her baby forever? please explain.....

they're both pretty bad. i just like sami better. i don't know, has sami ever tried to kill anyone? how many times has nicole attempted murder?

Sami. Her worst deeds were against her own family.

Present: Nicole

Past: Sami slighty cuz I compared their crimes and Sami's generally were worse and Sami I think has more than Nicole. True, Sami hasn't tried to murder anyone and she hasn't cheated on anyone like Nicole but I still say Sami's worse. But Nicole was very close behind. Plus, most of Sami's were against her family and friends.

Both characters have done some pretty bad things so in the end it doesn't matter much.

Sami has grown up and has feelings for others more than she has had in the past. And as far as cuddling her children and being around them, the writers have been the culprits in that type of SL. She's talking about them. Just because they aren't in the SL doesn't mean she's a terrible mom. On the other hand, when she was playing the younger mother, whoa, she was a little demon. I can't help but like Sami, and I really like Nichole, even though what she has done is unforgivable. I pretty much think it's a toss up with all their history up to now. Let me say I do like Nichole, what a great actress she is! Oh, and how can this all be Sami's fault? She didn't have anything to do with the baby switch or Nichole's miscarriage. JMHO

I completely agree and would like to add how terrible it is that Nicole is pretending to be Sami's friend, while holding the baby she stole from Sami. Not to mention all the terrible things she's done to Mia and Chad. How will they act after they find out their baby is dead?? Nicole has become just as evil as Kate and Stephano.

I like the new Sami and Nicole. In the old days I would have to say Sami was the worst, but finally the writers have Sami's character right. The worst person on the soap now is Kate. Deborah Adair played this character best. Kate has got the role down pat of being a jealous B , but theirs just no direction for her character to go from here. It will be boring just watching her be Stefano's puppet and wh---e.